Is Butler Paper Recycling Inc Safe? DOT 398521 – Safety Rating, Crashes & Violations

Q: What is the safety rating of Butler Paper Recycling Inc?

Butler Paper Recycling Inc has a safety rating of "Satisfactory" as of July 22, 2010, based on the most recent FMCSA compliance review.

This carrier is active with a Satisfactory safety rating.

Butler Paper Recycling Inc is a registered motor carrier with the FMCSA under USDOT number 398521. The company operates from Suffolk, VA and maintains an active operating status with 12 power units and 8 drivers on record.

Safety Rating

FMCSA Safety Rating

✓ Satisfactory

Rated: July 22, 2010

Butler Paper Recycling Inc holds a "Satisfactory" safety rating from the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA). This rating indicates that the carrier has been found to comply with federal safety regulations based on the most recent compliance review conducted by FMCSA. View official FMCSA record →

Inspection Summary

All-time Inspections

All-time

Total

OOS

Driver OOS

Vehicle OOS

11 inspections — relatively low volume, which may indicate a smaller or newer carrier.

OOS Rate0.00%

The out-of-service (OOS) rate represents the percentage of inspections that resulted in the carrier being placed out of service. This carrier has a 0% OOS rate — significantly better than the national average of ~21% for vehicles.

Crash History

Crash Records

All-time

Total

Fatal

Injuries

Tow-Away

2 crashes recorded. Low count, but crash data should always be reviewed alongside inspection history.

BASICS Safety Scores

BASICS Scores

Higher = more risk · FMCSA Behavior Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories

0.0

Unsafe Driving

Measures violations related to speeding, reckless driving, and improper lane changes.

0.0

HOS Compliance

Tracks hours-of-service violations, including driving beyond legal limits without rest.

0.0

Driver Fitness

Reflects issues with driver qualifications, licenses, and medical certifications.

0.0

Controlled Substances

Captures drug and alcohol violations, including failed or refused tests.

1.2

Vehicle Maintenance

Reflects brake, tire, lighting, and other equipment-related inspection violations.

Scores above 65 (general freight) or 50 (passenger/hazmat) trigger an FMCSA Alert. Higher scores indicate more safety risk. National median is approximately 20–30 for active carriers.

Other Carriers in Suffolk, VA

View all carriers in Suffolk, VA →

More Carriers in Virginia

View all carriers in Virginia →

Largest Trucking Companies →Safest Trucking Companies →

Carrier Insight

Butler Paper Recycling Inc is a medium-sized motor carrier operating in Virginia. With 11 total inspections on record, the carrier has an out-of-service rate of 0.0%, which is below the national average of approximately 21%. 2 crashes have been reported. Review crash details alongside fleet size and inspection history before making hiring decisions.

A Satisfactory rating from the FMCSA indicates that Butler Paper Recycling Inc meets federal safety standards based on the most recent compliance review. This is the highest rating a carrier can receive.

The company operates 12 power units and employs 8 drivers. This is a mid-sized operation relative to the broader carrier market.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is USDOT Number 398521?

USDOT number 398521 is assigned to Butler Paper Recycling Inc, an active motor carrier registered with the FMCSA, based in Suffolk, VA.

What is the safety rating of Butler Paper Recycling Inc?

Butler Paper Recycling Inc has a safety rating of Satisfactory as of July 22, 2010.

How many inspections has Butler Paper Recycling Inc had?

Butler Paper Recycling Inc has recorded 11 total inspections with 0 out-of-service orders, representing an OOS rate of 0.00%.

Where is Butler Paper Recycling Inc located?

Butler Paper Recycling Inc is headquartered at 324 Newport Street, Suffolk, VA 23434.

What does "Not Rated" mean?

"Not Rated" means the FMCSA has not conducted a formal compliance review for this carrier. It does not indicate a safety problem — many active carriers operate without a formal rating.

Is zero crashes always a good sign?

Generally yes, but context matters. A carrier with zero crashes and very few inspections may simply have limited road exposure. Always review crash data alongside inspection volume and fleet size.

What is a normal OOS rate?

The national average vehicle out-of-service rate is approximately 21%. Driver OOS averages around 5%. Rates significantly above these thresholds may indicate recurring compliance issues.

How often is FMCSA data updated?

FMCSA publishes updated carrier data monthly. This page reflects the most recent available snapshot, updated on the date shown above.

Data sourced from the FMCSA Open Data Portal. Updated monthly. DOT# 398521 · Last updated: 2026-03-09. View official FMCSA record →

Butler Paper Recycling Inc (DOT# 398521) – FMCSA Carrier Profile